Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Committed Philadelphia Injury Firm with Proven Trial Results
Get Your Free Consultation 215-372-8889
Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Lawyer / Blog / Wrongful Death / The Difference Between Criminal Charges and Civil Wrongful Death Lawsuits

The Difference Between Criminal Charges and Civil Wrongful Death Lawsuits

LegalPI

When a preventable death involves reckless, negligent, or intentional conduct, more than one legal case may follow. Prosecutors can bring criminal charges, while the family may have a separate right to pursue a wrongful death lawsuit for the losses caused by the death. Both cases can arise from the same death, but they serve different purposes and move through different parts of the court system.

Families often need to know whether the criminal case controls their ability to seek compensation. The answer depends on the civil claim, not simply on what prosecutors decide to do. Because a criminal prosecution and a wrongful death lawsuit follow different paths, working with an experienced Philadelphia wrongful death lawyer can help your family understand how the civil case can move forward even while criminal proceedings are still pending.

Criminal Prosecution and Wrongful Death Claims Serve Different Purposes

A criminal case addresses whether a person violated Pennsylvania law and should be held criminally responsible for causing another person’s death. The Commonwealth brings the prosecution, and a conviction can result in incarceration, probation, fines, or other penalties imposed by the court.

Pennsylvania law recognizes several forms of criminal homicide. Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 2501, criminal responsibility can arise when a person causes a death intentionally, knowingly, recklessly, or negligently. The facts surrounding the death determine which criminal charge, if any, prosecutors decide to pursue.

A wrongful death lawsuit serves a separate civil purpose. Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301, a claim may be brought when a death results from another party’s wrongful act, neglect, unlawful violence, or negligence. The civil action allows the family to pursue compensation for the losses caused by the death rather than criminal penalties.

The Commonwealth and the Family Have Different Roles

The prosecutor directs the criminal case on behalf of the Commonwealth. Family members may provide information to investigators, attend court proceedings, and exercise rights afforded to crime victims, but charging decisions and the continued prosecution of the case remain within the authority of the government.

A wrongful death claim proceeds separately through the civil court system. Pennsylvania law identifies the surviving spouse, children, and parents as the beneficiaries of a wrongful death recovery. Under Rule of Civil Procedure 2202, the decedent’s personal representative generally brings the action on their behalf. If no action is filed within six months of the death, a qualifying beneficiary may bring the claim as trustee ad litem for those entitled to share in the recovery.

Civil liability may also extend beyond the individual who is criminally charged. Depending on the circumstances, responsibility may involve a driver, employer, business, property owner, medical provider, manufacturer, or another party whose conduct contributed to the death.

Criminal and Civil Cases Use Different Burdens of Proof

The amount of proof required is one of the clearest differences between criminal and civil cases. In a criminal prosecution, the Commonwealth must prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The high standard reflects the serious consequences that can follow a criminal conviction.

A wrongful death action is decided under the lower civil standard of proof known as a preponderance of the evidence. In practical terms, the family must show that it is more likely than not that the defendant was legally responsible for the death.

The difference becomes especially important when the same death gives rise to both proceedings. Prosecutors may have evidence that raises serious concerns but does not satisfy the demanding criminal standard. A civil claim based on the same event can still succeed if the evidence is strong enough to meet the preponderance standard.

The Possible Outcomes Are Also Different

A criminal conviction can result in punishment imposed by the state. Depending on the offense, the court may order imprisonment, probation, fines, or other criminal penalties.

A wrongful death lawsuit can result in a settlement or civil judgment requiring the responsible party to pay damages. Pennsylvania’s wrongful death statute permits recovery of certain expenses associated with the fatal injury and death, including reasonable medical, funeral, and estate administration costs. Other recoverable losses can include financial contributions, services, and aspects of the family relationship recognized under Pennsylvania law.

Civil compensation addresses losses the criminal sentence does not. A family may have lost income the person provided, help with household responsibilities, parental guidance, companionship, or other forms of support that were part of everyday life before the death.

A Civil Wrongful Death Claim Can Continue Without Criminal Charges

A prosecutor may decide that the available evidence does not support filing criminal charges. Charges that are filed can later be reduced or dismissed, and a defendant may be acquitted at trial if the Commonwealth does not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The outcome of a criminal case does not determine whether the family has a viable civil claim. Pennsylvania law allows a wrongful death action when negligence, wrongful conduct, or unlawful violence causes a death, and that claim is evaluated under civil law and the lower civil burden of proof.

The evidence needed will depend on the circumstances surrounding the death. A fatal crash may involve vehicle data, photographs, witness accounts, or reconstruction evidence. A medical negligence case may rely on treatment records and expert opinions, while a death involving unsafe property or business conduct may require records showing what the responsible party knew and how the hazard was addressed.

A civil case can also identify responsibility that extends beyond the person investigated or charged criminally. The absence of a criminal conviction does not prevent the family from pursuing other parties whose conduct contributed to the death.

A Pending Criminal Case Does Not Stop the Civil Filing Deadline

Pennsylvania generally provides a two-year limitations period for actions seeking damages for a death caused by wrongful conduct under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524. A criminal investigation or prosecution can continue while that civil deadline is running.

Families may be focused on hearings, charging decisions, or an upcoming criminal trial while the civil filing deadline continues to run. During that time, important evidence may also be developing as records are collected, witnesses are interviewed, and the facts surrounding the death are examined more closely.

The criminal case does not control when a wrongful death action must be filed. The civil claim has its own deadline and needs to be protected separately. With the civil filing deadline running independently of the criminal case, consulting with a Philadelphia wrongful death lawyer can help determine what steps are available to pursue the family’s claim without waiting for the prosecution to conclude.

Contact The Villari Firm

If your family lost a loved one because of negligence, reckless conduct, or intentional wrongdoing, the criminal case may address only one aspect of the harm caused by the death. A separate wrongful death claim can provide a civil avenue for pursuing compensation for the financial and personal losses suffered by the family.

The Villari Firm represents families in Philadelphia and throughout Pennsylvania after deaths caused by negligence or wrongful conduct. Contact The Villari Firm to speak with an experienced Philadelphia wrongful death lawyer and learn how we can pursue financial accountability for the losses your family has suffered.

Sources:

  • Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania, How the Courts Operate
    https://www.pacourts.us/learn/how-the-courts-operate
  • Pennsylvania General Assembly, 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301, Death Action
    https://www.legis.state.pa.us/WU01/LI/LI/CT/HTM/42/00.083.001.000..HTM
  • Pennsylvania Code, Pa.R.C.P. 2202, Parties Entitled to Bring Action for Wrongful Death
    https://www.pacodeandbulletin.gov/Display/pacode?d=reduce&file=%2Fsecure%2Fpacode%2Fdata%2F231%2Fchapter2200%2Fs2202.html
  • Pennsylvania General Assembly, 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524, Two-Year Limitation
    https://www.legis.state.pa.us/WU01/LI/LI/CT/HTM/42/00.055.024.000..HTM
  • Pennsylvania General Assembly, 18 Pa.C.S. § 2501, Criminal Homicide
    https://www.legis.state.pa.us/WU01/LI/LI/CT/HTM/18/00.025.001.000..HTM